Allen Matkins
ProfessionalsIndustries & ServicesNews & InsightsCareers

  • Professionals
  • Industries & Services
  • News & Insights
  • Careers
  • Offices
  • About
Manage Subscriptions

News & Insights

Legal Alert

Ninth Circuit Bankruptcy Appellate Panel Holds that an Oversecured Creditor Is Entitled to Default Interest After the Petition Date and Before Plan Confirmation

Legal Alert

5.20.16

In Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Beltway One Dev. Grp., LLC (In re Beltway One Dev. Grp., LLC), 547 B.R. 819 (B.A.P. 9th Cir. 2016), the Ninth Circuit Bankruptcy Appellate Panel recently held that an oversecured creditor is entitled to pendency default interest, i.e., default interest accruing during the bankruptcy case, before plan confirmation where the secured creditor's claim is not cured under a debtor's reorganization plan.

Beltway One involved a $10 million matured, secured loan made by Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., which precipitated Beltway One's voluntary bankruptcy. The parties agreed that Wells Fargo was oversecured. Beltway One's reorganization plan proposed extending the maturity date of the loan for 30 years, while providing a "cramdown" interest rate of 4.25% with a balloon payment at maturity. Wells Fargo objected, arguing, among other things, that as an oversecured creditor it was entitled to pendency default interest under Bankruptcy Code section 506(b) because its claim was not cured under the plan – and, indeed, could not be cured. Beltway One conceded that Wells Fargo's claim was not cured, but argued that under Great Western Bank & Trust v. Entz-White Lumber and Supply, Inc. (In re Entz-White Lumber and Supply, Inc.), 850 F.2d 1338 (9th Cir. 1988), the bankruptcy court had "equitable discretion" to limit pendency interest. The bankruptcy court agreed, disallowed Wells Fargo's claim for pendency interest, and confirmed the Beltway One's plan.

On appeal, the BAP reversed the bankruptcy court, holding that "an oversecured creditor can record pendency interest as part of its allowed claim, at least to the extent it is oversecured." The BAP found Entz-White inapplicable noting that Wells Fargo's claim was impaired (i.e., not cured) under Beltway One's plan because it provided a new term, new interest rate, and new amortization schedule. The BAP further explained that a court's "equitable discretion" under Entz-White in awarding interest is limited to circumstances where a plan "cures and nullifies all consequences of default, but fails to establish the appropriate post-petition interest rate under the contract or applicable state law." The BAP also relied on General Elec. Capital Corp. v. Future Media Prods., Inc., 536 F.3d 969, 973 (9th Cir.), amended 547 F.3d 956, 960 (9th Cir. 2008) that an oversecured creditor is entitled to "a presumption of allowability for the contracted default rate of interest provided that the rate is not unenforceable under applicable non-bankruptcy law." Accordingly, the debtor, not the oversecured creditor, bears the burden of establishing that the pendency default interest rate is unenforceable under applicable non-bankruptcy law.

In sum, the BAP's decision in Beltway One clarified that when an oversecured creditor's claim is not cured by a reorganization plan, the secured creditor is entitled to pendency interest at the contractual rate, including default interest, unless a debtor can prove the rate is unenforceable under applicable non-bankruptcy law.

SUBSCRIBE

Author

William "Bill" W. Huckins

Partner

San FranciscoT(415) 273-7426whuckins@allenmatkins.com
Email William "Bill" W. Huckins
Download William "Bill" W. Huckins Vcard
William "Bill" W. Huckins LinkedIn

RELATED SERVICES

  • Restructuring, Insolvency & Bankruptcy

News & Insights

Manage Subscriptions

Press, Media, & Articles

Landlords Race to Sort Out Tenant Guarantees From SVB

3.14.23

Press, Media, & Articles

SVB Collapse Leaves Some Bay Area Life Science Tenants Without a Crucial Line of Credit

3.14.23

Picture of chess piece on chess board

Press, Media, & Articles

3 Ways SVB, Signature Failures Will Rattle Real Estate

3.13.23

Press, Media, & Articles

First Republic Woe Shows End of Easy Money That Drove California

3.13.23

Event

Receivers' Huddle Series: Bar Orders post Purdue Pharma

6.10.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Second Rite Aid Bankruptcy Underscores Importance of Vendor Role

5.14.25

Picture of chess piece on chess board

Press, Media, & Articles

Ivan Gold Comments on Modular Home Crisis in San Francisco Chronicle

2.03.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Big Lots Sale Hearing to Continue Tomorrow, Dec. 31, at 10 am ET; Debtors Warn Sale to Gordon Brothers Must Close This Week

1.02.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Big Lots Sale to Nexus Falls Apart, Plans to Close Business

12.19.24

Press, Media, & Articles

64 Allen Matkins Lawyers Recognized in Best Lawyers in America®

8.15.24

Picture of chess piece on chess board

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins Represents Smart Earth Technologies LLC in Confirming Chapter 11 Plan that Resolves Over $100 Million in Liabilities

3.27.24

Press, Media, & Articles

WeWork Explores Bankruptcy Loan Options Amid Landlord Dispute

2.05.24

Press, Media, & Articles

WeWork Presses Landlords For Ch. 11 Lease Concessions

2.05.24

Press, Media, & Articles

WeWork Looks to Renegotiate Most of Its Leases as It Fights to Survive

9.06.23

Photo of mountains with trees and grass in the foreground

Press, Media, & Articles

38 Allen Matkins Partners Recognized in 2024 Edition of The Best Lawyers in America®; Keith Bishop, Jeff Chine, and Val Hoy Named ‘Lawyers of the Year’; 16 Additional Lawyers Named to ‘Ones to Watch’ List

8.17.23

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins Welcomes Bankruptcy and Creditors’ Rights Partner Matthew G. Bouslog to its Orange County Office

6.12.23

Press, Media, & Articles

Landlords Race to Sort Out Tenant Guarantees From SVB

3.14.23

Press, Media, & Articles

SVB Collapse Leaves Some Bay Area Life Science Tenants Without a Crucial Line of Credit

3.14.23

Picture of chess piece on chess board

Press, Media, & Articles

3 Ways SVB, Signature Failures Will Rattle Real Estate

3.13.23

Press, Media, & Articles

First Republic Woe Shows End of Easy Money That Drove California

3.13.23

Event

Receivers' Huddle Series: Bar Orders post Purdue Pharma

6.10.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Second Rite Aid Bankruptcy Underscores Importance of Vendor Role

5.14.25

Picture of chess piece on chess board

Press, Media, & Articles

Ivan Gold Comments on Modular Home Crisis in San Francisco Chronicle

2.03.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Big Lots Sale Hearing to Continue Tomorrow, Dec. 31, at 10 am ET; Debtors Warn Sale to Gordon Brothers Must Close This Week

1.02.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Big Lots Sale to Nexus Falls Apart, Plans to Close Business

12.19.24

Press, Media, & Articles

64 Allen Matkins Lawyers Recognized in Best Lawyers in America®

8.15.24

Picture of chess piece on chess board

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins Represents Smart Earth Technologies LLC in Confirming Chapter 11 Plan that Resolves Over $100 Million in Liabilities

3.27.24

Press, Media, & Articles

WeWork Explores Bankruptcy Loan Options Amid Landlord Dispute

2.05.24

Press, Media, & Articles

WeWork Presses Landlords For Ch. 11 Lease Concessions

2.05.24

Press, Media, & Articles

WeWork Looks to Renegotiate Most of Its Leases as It Fights to Survive

9.06.23

Photo of mountains with trees and grass in the foreground

Press, Media, & Articles

38 Allen Matkins Partners Recognized in 2024 Edition of The Best Lawyers in America®; Keith Bishop, Jeff Chine, and Val Hoy Named ‘Lawyers of the Year’; 16 Additional Lawyers Named to ‘Ones to Watch’ List

8.17.23

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins Welcomes Bankruptcy and Creditors’ Rights Partner Matthew G. Bouslog to its Orange County Office

6.12.23

Press, Media, & Articles

Landlords Race to Sort Out Tenant Guarantees From SVB

3.14.23

Press, Media, & Articles

SVB Collapse Leaves Some Bay Area Life Science Tenants Without a Crucial Line of Credit

3.14.23

Picture of chess piece on chess board

Press, Media, & Articles

3 Ways SVB, Signature Failures Will Rattle Real Estate

3.13.23

Press, Media, & Articles

First Republic Woe Shows End of Easy Money That Drove California

3.13.23

View All
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Request Personal Data Information

Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP. All Rights Reserved.

Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter
Instagram

This publication is made available by Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP for educational purposes only to convey general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this website you acknowledge there is no attorney client relationship between you and Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP. This publication should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney applied to your circumstances. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Full Disclaimer