Allen Matkins
ProfessionalsIndustries & ServicesNews & InsightsCareers

  • Professionals
  • Industries & Services
  • News & Insights
  • Careers
  • Offices
  • About
Manage Subscriptions

Environmental Enforcement and Litigation

Cleanup Litigation

We represent clients in state and federal courts and in arbitration and mediation regarding sites with soil, surface water or groundwater contamination.

We represent clients in:

  • Cost recovery and natural resource damages under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA)
  • Cases between private entities, typically involving cost recovery or contribution claims under CERCLA or its state law counterparts such as:
  • The California Hazardous Substance Account Act
  • Citizen suits under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA)
  • Claims based on common law theories such as nuisance, trespass and ultra-hazardous activity

We represent clients in:

  • Cost recovery and natural resource damages under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA)
  • Cases between private entities, typically involving cost recovery or contribution claims under CERCLA or its state law counterparts such as:
  • The California Hazardous Substance Account Act
  • Citizen suits under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA)
  • Claims based on common law theories such as nuisance, trespass and ultra-hazardous activity

"Excellent combination of environmental and legal knowledge."

- General Counsel, Oil and Gas Company

EXPERIENCE

  • Mercury Mine. Represented alleged successor in interest to former owner of defunct mercury minesite in action involving responsibility for cleanup costs. Trial resulted in judgment on third party claim for contribution of response costs from successor to World War II - era investment bank found to be an "operator" of the minesite.
  • Railroad. Represented railroad before jury in fraud and rescission action by residential developer based on alleged failure to disclose subsurface petroleum storage facilities in connection with sale of real property.
  • Industrial Waste Management Company. Represented defendants and cross-claimants in action involving soil and groundwater contamination of industrial site in California with VOCs and other compounds.
  • Private Party. Represented private party in administrative litigation contesting a Water Code §13304 cleanup and abatement order regarding perchlorate contamination of groundwater in California.
  • Oil Company. Represented large oil company in defending cost recovery actions in Northern California relating to petroleum, hydrocarbon and other soil and groundwater contamination relating to former service station operations. Participant in many mediations of such disputes.
  • Site Operator. Represented alleged former operator of property with contaminated groundwater in implied indemnity action.
  • Water Company. Represented privately-owned water company in action against USAF for contamination of groundwater supplies near a former air base.
  • Manufacturing Company. Represented manufacturing company, alleged successor to former owner of defunct mercury mine site in California, in settlement through consent decree of state and federal trustees' natural resource damages claim under CERCLA.
  • Water Company. Represented privately-owned water company in action against responsible parties for contamination of groundwater supplies.
  • Industrial Property Owner. Represented owner of commercial/industrial property in California in action for contribution, breach of contract and damages under various common law theories against former tenant responsible for VOC contamination.
  • Property Owner. Represented downgradient owner of property in successful arbitration of dispute regarding operation of option agreement against successor to chemical manufacturer regarding soil and groundwater contamination with arsenic.
  • Solvent Recycling Company. Representing plaintiffs in action to enforce environmental defense and indemnity provisions of complex merger agreement. Prevailed in U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, obtaining ruling that clients are entitled to full indemnity and declaratory relief.
  • Landfill Company. Represented proponent of proposed multimillion dollar Class III landfill in litigation.
  • Site Operator. Represented alleged former site operator in federal and state court litigation brought under CERCLA, HSAA, and state law common law theories.
  • Property Owner. Represented plaintiff owner of property with contaminated groundwater in CERCLA action.
  • Property Owner. Represented alleged former owner of contaminated property in CERCLA action.
  • Site Operator. Represented alleged former operator of property with contaminated groundwater in implied indemnity action.
  • Water Company. Represented privately-owned water company in action against USAF for contamination of groundwater supplies near a former air base.
  • Manufacturing Company. Represented manufacturing company, alleged successor to former owner of defunct mercury mine site in California, in settlement through consent decree of state and federal trustees' natural resource damages claim under CERCLA.
  • Water Company. Represented privately-owned water company in action against responsible parties for contamination of groundwater supplies.
  • Industrial Property Owner. Represented owner of commercial/industrial property in California in action for contribution, breach of contract and damages under various common law theories against former tenant responsible for VOC contamination.
  • Property Owner. Represented downgradient owner of property in successful arbitration of dispute regarding operation of option agreement against successor to chemical manufacturer regarding soil and groundwater contamination with arsenic.
  • Solvent Recycling Company. Representing plaintiffs in action to enforce environmental defense and indemnity provisions of complex merger agreement. Prevailed in U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, obtaining ruling that clients are entitled to full indemnity and declaratory relief.
  • Landfill Company. Represented proponent of proposed multimillion dollar Class III landfill in litigation.
  • Site Operator. Represented alleged former site operator in federal and state court litigation brought under CERCLA, HSAA, and state law common law theories.
  • Property Owner. Represented plaintiff owner of property with contaminated groundwater in CERCLA action.
  • Property Owner. Represented alleged former owner of contaminated property in CERCLA action.
  • Related  Services

  • Environmental & Natural Resources

  • Real Estate Services

  • Litigation & Counseling

News & Insights

Manage Subscriptions

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

7.03.25

Press, Media, & Articles

How CEQA Reforms Address California's Housing Squeeze

7.03.25

Photo of mountains with trees and grass in the foreground

Legal Alert

Effective Immediately: CEQA Reform Legislation

7.02.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Daily Journal Recognizes Three Allen Matkins Partners as Top Real Estate & Development Lawyers

7.02.25

Event

Allen Matkins 18th Annual View From the Top

9.08.25

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

8.08.25

Ground up view of skyscrapers at dusk

Press, Media, & Articles

Summer 2025 Allen Matkins/UCLA Anderson California CRE Forecast Reveals Tariff Uncertainty and Rising Costs are Stalling Over a Third of California CRE Projects

8.06.25

Legal Alert

White House Aims To Accelerate Environmental Permitting For Data Centers

8.06.25

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

8.01.25

Newsletter

Special Water Supply Edition: California Environmental Law & Policy Update

7.25.25

Picture of chess piece on chess board

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins Secures Major Federal Court Victory in High-Stakes Land Dispute

7.23.25

Event

CEQA Reform Legislation and the Impact of AB 130 and SB 131

7.23.25

Legal Alert

Bonus Depreciation Is Back! And Other Big Beautiful Taxes

7.22.25

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

7.18.25

Photo of mountains with trees and grass in the foreground

Legal Alert

Project Applicants Can Now Pay for Expedited Federal Environmental Review Under NEPA

7.16.25

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

7.11.25

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

7.03.25

Press, Media, & Articles

How CEQA Reforms Address California's Housing Squeeze

7.03.25

Photo of mountains with trees and grass in the foreground

Legal Alert

Effective Immediately: CEQA Reform Legislation

7.02.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Daily Journal Recognizes Three Allen Matkins Partners as Top Real Estate & Development Lawyers

7.02.25

Event

Allen Matkins 18th Annual View From the Top

9.08.25

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

8.08.25

Ground up view of skyscrapers at dusk

Press, Media, & Articles

Summer 2025 Allen Matkins/UCLA Anderson California CRE Forecast Reveals Tariff Uncertainty and Rising Costs are Stalling Over a Third of California CRE Projects

8.06.25

Legal Alert

White House Aims To Accelerate Environmental Permitting For Data Centers

8.06.25

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

8.01.25

Newsletter

Special Water Supply Edition: California Environmental Law & Policy Update

7.25.25

Picture of chess piece on chess board

Press, Media, & Articles

Allen Matkins Secures Major Federal Court Victory in High-Stakes Land Dispute

7.23.25

Event

CEQA Reform Legislation and the Impact of AB 130 and SB 131

7.23.25

Legal Alert

Bonus Depreciation Is Back! And Other Big Beautiful Taxes

7.22.25

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

7.18.25

Photo of mountains with trees and grass in the foreground

Legal Alert

Project Applicants Can Now Pay for Expedited Federal Environmental Review Under NEPA

7.16.25

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

7.11.25

Newsletter

California Environmental Law & Policy Update

7.03.25

Press, Media, & Articles

How CEQA Reforms Address California's Housing Squeeze

7.03.25

Photo of mountains with trees and grass in the foreground

Legal Alert

Effective Immediately: CEQA Reform Legislation

7.02.25

Press, Media, & Articles

Daily Journal Recognizes Three Allen Matkins Partners as Top Real Estate & Development Lawyers

7.02.25

  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Request Personal Data Information

Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP. All Rights Reserved.

Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter
Instagram

This publication is made available by Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP for educational purposes only to convey general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this website you acknowledge there is no attorney client relationship between you and Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory & Natsis LLP. This publication should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney applied to your circumstances. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Full Disclaimer